During peak tourist seasons, plan an extra 20 minutes at RSW for check-in due to smaller airline ticket counters.

| Most accurate provider | Mytrip 3 stars | 
|---|---|
| Most trusted provider | Mytrip 3 stars | 
| Round-trip from | $127 (CheapOair) | 
| One-way from | $74 (American Airlines) | 
| Popular in | April | 
| Cheapest in | September | 
| Average price | $207 | 
Fly from
Fly to
Route
Depart
Return
Price
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Thu 11/13
6:00 am-8:53 am
Nonstop2h 53m
Newark
Sun 11/16
6:20 pm-9:36 pm
Nonstop3h 16m
Fort MyersNew York
RSW - LGA
RSWLGA
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Thu 11/13
7:30 pm-10:19 pm
Nonstop2h 49m
New York LaGuardia
Sun 11/16
7:10 am-10:27 am
Nonstop3h 17m
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Fri 1/16
9:00 pm-11:52 pm
Nonstop2h 52m
Newark
Mon 1/19
9:00 am-12:21 pm
Nonstop3h 21m
Fort MyersNew York
RSW - LGA
RSWLGA
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Tue 11/11
6:55 am-2:39 pm
1 stop7h 44m
New York LaGuardia
Sat 11/15
9:59 am-4:33 pm
1 stop6h 34m
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Fri 11/14
5:03 pm-7:56 pm
Nonstop2h 53m
Newark
Mon 11/17
8:59 am-12:18 pm
Nonstop3h 19m
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Thu 12/4
7:11 am-10:00 am
Nonstop2h 49m
Newark
Sat 12/6
4:38 pm-7:49 pm
Nonstop3h 11m
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Tue 11/11
5:35 am-10:51 am
1 stop5h 16m
Newark
Sat 11/15
9:35 am-4:51 pm
1 stop7h 16m
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Sat 12/6
7:11 am-10:00 am
Nonstop2h 49m
Newark
Sun 12/7
4:34 pm-7:45 pm
Nonstop3h 11m
Fort MyersNewark
RSW - EWR
RSWEWR
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Fri 11/14
5:03 pm-7:56 pm
Nonstop2h 53m
Newark
Sun 11/16
8:59 am-12:18 pm
Nonstop3h 19m
Fort MyersNew York
RSW - JFK
RSWJFK
Fort Myers SW Florida Intl
Wed 12/24
9:20 pm-12:04 am
Nonstop2h 44m
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Fri 1/2
8:59 pm-12:23 am
Nonstop3h 24m
| Provider | Price Accuracy | Trust Score* | 
|---|---|---|
| Price Accuracy2 stars | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy3 stars | Trust Score*1 star | |
| Price Accuracy3 stars | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy1 star | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy3 stars | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy3 stars | Trust Score*2 stars | 
Booking 46 days in advance of your planned departure date is, on average, the best time to get cheap flights from Fort Myers to New York. The general trend is that the closer you book to the departure date, the more expensive your flight will be.
Currently, September is the cheapest month in which you can book a flight from Fort Myers to New York (average of $64). Flying from Fort Myers to New York in May is currently the most expensive (average of $89). There are several factors that can impact the price of a flight, so comparing airlines, departure airports and flight times can provide users with more options.
One of the essential ways to save on airfare from Fort Myers to New York is to remain as flexible as possible. Flights that are in the afternoon tend to be the most expensive. A flight in the evening could potentially save you up to 47% on airfare.
Travelers seeking maximum savings on their Fort Myers to New York flight should consider departing on Monday at noon when fares are most often at their lowest. Sunday afternoons flights should be avoided if possible as fares are typically the most expensive at this time.
Crew
Boarding
Comfort
Entertainment
Food
Overall
Reviews
Anonymous,Jul 2025
RIC - BDL
Crew
Boarding
Comfort
Entertainment
Food
Overall
Reviews
Anonymous,Jul 2025
RIC - BDL
Crew
Boarding
Comfort
Entertainment
Food
Overall
Reviews
Anonymous,Jul 2025
RIC - BDL
Crew
Boarding
Comfort
Entertainment
Food
Overall
Reviews
Anonymous,Jul 2025
RIC - BDL
Crew
Boarding
Comfort
Entertainment
Food
Overall
Reviews
Anonymous,Jul 2025
RIC - BDL
Crew
Boarding
Comfort
Entertainment
Food
Overall
Reviews
Anonymous,Jul 2025
RIC - BDL
| Airline | Cheapest | Average | Flexibility | On-time | 
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest$27 | Average$248 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time62% | |
| Cheapest$73 | Average$169 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time65% | |
| Cheapest$78 | Average$216 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-timeN/A | |
| Cheapest$90 | Average$195 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time62% | |
| Cheapest$127 | Average$256 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time69% | |
| Cheapest$146 | Average$238 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time71% |