
Most accurate provider | FlightHub 3 stars |
|---|---|
Most trusted provider | FlightHub 3 stars |
Round-trip from | $254 (Kiwi.com) |
One-way from | $86 (Kiwi.com) |
Popular in | April |
Cheapest in | February |
Average price | $366 |
Good round-trip deal | $291 or less |
Good one-way deal | $194 or less |
Fly from
Fly to
Route
Depart
Return
New WindsorIndianapolis
SWF - IND
SWFIND
New Windsor Stewart
Fri 7/17
12:17 pm-11:25 pm
1 stop11h 08m
Indianapolis
Wed 7/22
12:20 pm-9:38 am
2 stops21h 18m
New YorkIndianapolis
JFK - IND
JFKIND
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Tue 7/7
1:58 pm-4:30 pm
Nonstop2h 32m
Indianapolis
Tue 7/14
12:52 pm-3:15 pm
Nonstop2h 23m
NewarkIndianapolis
EWR - IND
EWRIND
Newark
Fri 9/4
6:59 pm-12:34 am
1 stop5h 35m
Indianapolis
Mon 9/7
6:25 pm-11:05 pm
1 stop4h 40m
New YorkIndianapolis
JFK - IND
JFKIND
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Wed 7/1
6:00 am-12:40 pm
1 stop6h 40m
Indianapolis
Wed 7/8
5:30 pm-10:11 pm
1 stop4h 41m
New YorkIndianapolis
LGA - IND
LGAIND
New York LaGuardia
Mon 7/6
2:42 pm-5:11 pm
Nonstop2h 29m
Indianapolis
Tue 7/14
11:05 am-1:11 pm
Nonstop2h 06m
New YorkIndianapolis
LGA - IND
LGAIND
New York LaGuardia
Wed 7/1
5:45 pm-8:24 pm
Nonstop2h 39m
Indianapolis
Sun 7/5
8:05 am-10:14 am
Nonstop2h 09m
New WindsorIndianapolis
SWF - IND
SWFIND
New Windsor Stewart
Fri 6/5
5:55 pm-10:39 am
1 stop16h 44m
Indianapolis
Sat 6/20
6:15 am-5:55 pm
1 stop11h 40m
New YorkIndianapolis
JFK - IND
JFKIND
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Thu 5/28
6:20 pm-8:50 pm
Nonstop2h 30m
Indianapolis
Tue 6/2
10:10 am-4:15 pm
1 stop6h 05m
New YorkIndianapolis
JFK - IND
JFKIND
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Wed 5/27
8:00 am-12:56 pm
1 stop4h 56m
Indianapolis
Tue 6/9
6:51 am-9:00 am
Nonstop2h 09m
New YorkIndianapolis
JFK - IND
JFKIND
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Mon 7/6
6:00 am-12:40 pm
1 stop6h 40m
Indianapolis
Tue 7/14
7:01 am-12:00 pm
1 stop4h 59m
| Provider | Price Accuracy | Trust Score* |
|---|---|---|
| Price Accuracy1 star | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy3 stars | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy2 stars | Trust Score*1 star | |
| Price Accuracy3 stars | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy2 stars | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy1 star | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy- | Trust Score*3 stars | |
| Price Accuracy1 star | Trust Score*3 stars |
Currently, January is the cheapest month in which you can book a flight from New York to Indianapolis (average of $86). Flying from New York to Indianapolis in March is currently the most expensive (average of $718). There are several factors that can impact the price of a flight, so comparing airlines, departure airports and flight times can provide users with more options.
One of the essential ways to save on airfare from New York to Indianapolis is to remain as flexible as possible. Flights that are in the morning tend to be the most expensive. A flight at noon could potentially save you up to 11% on airfare.
The most flights from NYC to IND are scheduled on a Sunday (45 on average). You will have fewer flight options on Saturday, which is when the least amount of flights are scheduled (34 on average).
About 22% of weekly flights between New York and Indianapolis have experienced delays in the past year, with the average delay time being 161 minutes.
Historically, flights departing in the morning are less likely to be delayed, whereas flights leaving at night tend to experience delays more often.
Wednesday tends to have the lowest number of delays on this route, whereas Sunday has historically faced a higher average of delays compared to other days of the week.
Over the last year, Delta have had the lowest number of delays on this route, with just 18% of flights being delayed.
To ensure you get the cheapest price possible for a flight from New York to Indianapolis, you should look to book at least 29 days in advance of your intended travel date. The price of your flight may increase if you delay and leave booking until a week or so before departure.
Travelers seeking maximum savings on their New York to Indianapolis flight should consider departing on Saturday evenings when fares are most often at their lowest. Monday mornings flights should be avoided if possible as fares are typically the most expensive at this time.
Overall
Comfort
Crew
Entertainment
Boarding
Food
Reviews
Dominic,Mar 2026
MCO - SMF
Overall
Comfort
Crew
Entertainment
Boarding
Food
Reviews
Dominic,Mar 2026
MCO - SMF
Overall
Comfort
Crew
Entertainment
Boarding
Food
Reviews
Dominic,Mar 2026
MCO - SMF
Overall
Comfort
Crew
Entertainment
Boarding
Food
Reviews
Dominic,Mar 2026
MCO - SMF
Overall
Comfort
Crew
Entertainment
Boarding
Food
Reviews
Dominic,Mar 2026
MCO - SMF
Overall
Comfort
Crew
Entertainment
Boarding
Food
Reviews
Dominic,Mar 2026
MCO - SMF
| Airline | Cheapest | Average | Flexibility | On-time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest$40 | Average$128 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time65% | |
| Cheapest$144 | Average$307 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-timeN/A | |
| Cheapest$174 | Average$318 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time71% | |
| Cheapest$189 | Average$366 | FlexibilityNo cancel fee | On-time69% |