HomeSearch by dateVacation packagesHotelsFlight dealsCar rentalTravel tips & news
Islamorada

$43+ Cheap flights from New York, NY (NYC) to Islamorada, FL

This is the cheapest one-way flight price found by a Cheapflights user in the last 72 hours by searching for a flight departing on 1/28. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel.
NYC — MIA
Feb 18 — Feb 251
Wed 2/18
Wed 2/25
1 adult, Economy
We work with more than 300 partners to bring you better travel deals

Find cheap flights from New York to Islamorada with Cheapflights

1. Tell us where you want to go

Enter your travel information like dates, passengers, trip type (one-way or round trip), and preferred cabin class then click “Find deals”

2. Select your favorite providers

We find the providers serving your travel needs. Choose up to four travel providers to compare side-by-side for flights, hotels, or car rentals.

3. Compare prices and book

Review each provider’s pricing and select the best option for you! Book through your favorite provider’s website for a seamless experience.
Cheapflights Tip: The best prices from New York to Islamorada are usually found in September or October, booked 14 days in advance, depart on a Tuesday or Monday and return on a Friday

Cheap flight deals from New York to Islamorada

Keep the following information in mind while searching for New York to Islamorada flight deals. Data was last updated January 19, 2026.

Most accurate provider

CheapOair
3 stars

Most trusted provider

CheapOair
3 stars

Round-trip from

$71
(Cheapflightsfares)

One-way from

$43
(Kiwi.com)

Popular in

December

Cheapest in

September

Average price

$209
Provider with most accurate pricing for New York (NYC)-Miami flight deals.
Search Deals
Provider most trusted by Cheapflights users for New York (NYC)-Miami flights.
Search Deals
From New York (NYC) to Islamorada
Search Deals
One-way flight from New York (NYC) to Islamorada
Search Deals
Highest demand for flights based on searches. 8% potential increase in price ($19 potential increase over avg. RT price).
Search Deals
Cheapest flight prices on average. 3% potential price decrease ($7 potential savings vs. average RT price).
Search Deals
Average for round-trip flights in January 2026
Search Deals

Find flight deals from New York to Islamorada

Cheapest flights from New York to Islamorada
Explore the most affordable flight options available from New York to Islamorada. Find the lowest fares from popular airlines and budget airlines, with prices last updated on January 19, 2026.

This Booking.com deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/18. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Booking.com is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Sun 2/110:02 am
JFK
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 19m
Frontier
Fri 2/66:00 am
MIA
-
JFK
Nonstop3h 07m
Frontier
Deal found 1/18$71
This Cheapflightsfares deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Cheapflightsfares is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Sat 2/218:45 pm
LGA
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 14m
Spirit Airlines
Tue 2/246:02 am
MIA
-
LGA
Nonstop2h 58m
Spirit Airlines
Deal found 1/17$71
This Frontier deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/18. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Frontier is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Sun 2/2210:02 am
JFK
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 19m
Frontier
Fri 2/276:00 am
MIA
-
JFK
Nonstop3h 07m
Frontier
Deal found 1/18$72
This Kiwi.com deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Kiwi.com is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Tue 2/1710:00 pm
LGA
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 14m
Multiple Airlines
Wed 2/184:10 pm
MIA
-
LGA
Nonstop2h 50m
Multiple Airlines
Deal found 1/17$72
This Frontier deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/16. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Frontier is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Sun 3/110:02 am
JFK
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 19m
Frontier
Wed 3/117:00 am
MIA
-
JFK
Nonstop3h 07m
Frontier
Deal found 1/16$73
This Kiwi.com deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Kiwi.com is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Tue 2/1010:00 pm
LGA
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 14m
Multiple Airlines
Thu 2/196:02 am
MIA
-
LGA
Nonstop2h 58m
Multiple Airlines
Deal found 1/17$73
This Frontier deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Frontier is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Wed 1/2810:02 am
JFK
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 19m
Frontier
Tue 2/36:00 am
MIA
-
JFK
Nonstop3h 07m
Frontier
Deal found 1/17$74
This Frontier deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Frontier is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Tue 3/1010:55 pm
LGA
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 14m
Frontier
Wed 3/116:54 pm
MIA
-
LGA
Nonstop3h 11m
Frontier
Deal found 1/17$74
This CheapOair deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure CheapOair is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Mon 2/2310:59 am
LGA
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 22m
Spirit Airlines
Tue 3/36:02 am
MIA
-
LGA
Nonstop2h 58m
Spirit Airlines
Deal found 1/17$75
This Super.com deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/18. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Super.com is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Tue 1/2710:02 am
JFK
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 19m
Frontier
Sat 1/316:00 am
MIA
-
JFK
Nonstop3h 07m
Frontier
Deal found 1/18$76
This Cheapflightsfares deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Cheapflightsfares is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Mon 2/98:39 pm
LGA
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 20m
Spirit Airlines
Fri 2/136:02 am
MIA
-
LGA
Nonstop2h 58m
Spirit Airlines
Deal found 1/17$76
This Trip.com deal was found by Cheapflights users on 1/17. Clicking the “Pick Dates” button in this card will allow you to select your dates and further customize your flight criteria. From there, click “Find deals”, make sure Trip.com is selected, and click “Compare selected” under the list of providers to see comparable flight deals.
Tue 3/310:02 am
JFK
-
MIA
Nonstop3h 19m
Frontier
Tue 3/107:00 am
MIA
-
JFK
Nonstop3h 07m
Frontier
Deal found 1/17$77

Cheapflights Fare Finder

 
Customize your flight search to find flights from New York to Islamorada that fit within your specific budget. Explore options based on user searches and filter the results based on your desired price range. Find flights that match your budget for a cost-effective journey. Over the last 7 days, Cheapflights users made 2,558,603 searches. Data last updated January 19, 2026.
Use the filters below to find and compare flights from New York to Islamorada that are best for you.

Fly from

New York

Fly to

Islamorada

Route

Depart

Return

Price

New YorkMiami

LGA - MIA

LGAMIA

New York LaGuardia

Sun 2/1

8:39 pm-11:59 pm

Nonstop3h 20m

Miami

Fri 2/6

4:01 pm-7:00 pm

Nonstop2h 59m

$111

NewarkMiami

EWR - MIA

EWRMIA

Newark

Sat 2/28

7:15 pm-10:35 pm

Nonstop3h 20m

Miami

Tue 3/3

6:30 pm-9:42 pm

Nonstop3h 12m

$137

New YorkMiami

LGA - MIA

LGAMIA

New York LaGuardia

Sat 4/11

5:59 pm-9:22 pm

Nonstop3h 23m

Miami

Thu 4/16

7:00 am-9:59 am

Nonstop2h 59m

$147

New YorkMiami

JFK - MIA

JFKMIA

New York John F Kennedy Intl

Wed 2/18

1:10 pm-4:31 pm

Nonstop3h 21m

Miami

Sat 2/28

7:40 am-10:30 am

Nonstop2h 50m

$147

NewarkMiami

EWR - MIA

EWRMIA

Newark

Sat 2/7

5:05 pm-8:29 pm

Nonstop3h 24m

Miami

Tue 2/10

7:15 am-10:21 am

Nonstop3h 06m

$147

New YorkMiami

JFK - MIA

JFKMIA

New York John F Kennedy Intl

Wed 2/4

7:05 am-10:24 am

Nonstop3h 19m

Miami

Wed 2/11

11:39 am-2:39 pm

Nonstop3h 00m

$147

NewarkMiami

EWR - MIA

EWRMIA

Newark

Sat 4/25

7:29 am-10:42 am

Nonstop3h 13m

Miami

Tue 4/28

7:01 am-10:12 am

Nonstop3h 11m

$147

New YorkMiami

JFK - MIA

JFKMIA

New York John F Kennedy Intl

Tue 2/17

3:29 pm-6:54 pm

Nonstop3h 25m

Miami

Tue 3/17

7:59 pm-11:10 pm

Nonstop3h 11m

$147

New YorkMiami

JFK - MIA

JFKMIA

New York John F Kennedy Intl

Sat 1/31

3:29 pm-6:54 pm

Nonstop3h 25m

Miami

Fri 2/6

11:39 am-2:39 pm

Nonstop3h 00m

$147

New YorkMiami

JFK - MIA

JFKMIA

New York John F Kennedy Intl

Sat 4/11

3:35 pm-6:59 pm

Nonstop3h 24m

Miami

Sun 4/19

7:40 am-10:31 am

Nonstop2h 51m

$147

Flights are sorted by cheapest round-trip flights first.

Deals found on 1/18

Showing 1-10 of 60 results
1
2
3
...
6

Best time to book a flight from New York to Islamorada

Have a flexible travel schedule? Discover the best time to fly to Islamorada from New York with our price prediction graph.
Estimated round-trip price
Rates are based on past data. Find the cheapest month and day to book your flight based on your travel requirements, then search for cheap deals.

Cheapflights Insights

Everything you need to know about your flight from New York to Islamorada

How far ahead should I book a flight from New York to Islamorada?

Use this chart to determine the optimal time to book a round-trip flight from New York to Islamorada. Price data was last updated on January 16, 2026.

The price you pay for your flight from New York to Islamorada may vary depending on when you book. For the best chance of a lower fare, look to book 14 days in advance of your trip. Fares are likely to increase a fortnight or so before your departure date.

What is the cheapest month to book a flight from New York to Islamorada?

Currently, March is the cheapest month in which you can book a flight from New York to Islamorada (average of $36). Flying from New York to Islamorada in July is currently the most expensive (average of $85). There are several factors that can impact the price of a flight, so comparing airlines, departure airports and flight times can provide users with more options.

What is the cheapest time of day to fly from NYC to I5L?

Find hourly flight availability from New York to Islamorada. Discover flight options and departure times throughout the day, allowing you to choose a departure time that suits your schedule. Data last updated January 19, 2026.

When flying from New York to Islamorada, the time of day you fly usually plays a role in the price. Save by searching for a flight in the evening, which can drop the price by up to 22% versus a flight in the morning.

What is the cheapest day to fly from New York to Islamorada?

Use this chart to determine the cheapest time to fly round-trip from New York to Islamorada. Price data was last updated on January 17, 2026.

Travelers seeking maximum savings on their New York to Islamorada flight should consider departing on Saturday at noon when fares are most often at their lowest. Saturday afternoons flights should be avoided if possible as fares are typically the most expensive at this time.

Weekly flight availability from New York to Islamorada

Explore weekly flight availability from New York to Islamorada. Discover flights operating on different days of the week, giving you the flexibility to choose a travel day that best fits your plans. Compare info to find the most convenient option for your journey. Data last updated January 19, 2026.

The most flights from NYC to I5L are scheduled on a Friday (127 on average). You will have fewer flight options on Wednesday, which is when the least amount of flights are scheduled (90 on average).

How much does it cost to fly round-trip from New York to Islamorada?

Reviews of airlines servicing Islamorada

Get insights into the airlines that provide service to Islamorada. Read reviews, discover amenities, and learn about the overall travel experience offered by airlines. Use this information to make informed decisions when choosing an airline for your flight to Islamorada. Reviews last updated January 19, 2026.
Read reviews from past customers who have flown Delta, United Airlines, and American Airlines from New York to Islamorada. Reviews also offer insight into each airline's entertainment options, comfort, food, crew/service, and boarding process.
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews

Overall

7.9

Food

7.2

Boarding

8.1

Comfort

7.9

Crew

8.5

Entertainment

7.8

Reviews

1 / 20
10.0
Excellent

Kymberlee,Oct 2024

JFK - ATL

Overall it was good on the flight. Before the flight with checking the bag at JFK was a nightmare. It took way too long and the Delta concierge was very rude to everyone. But other than that it was fine.
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews

Overall

7.9

Food

7.2

Boarding

8.1

Comfort

7.9

Crew

8.5

Entertainment

7.8

Reviews

1 / 20
10.0
Excellent

Kymberlee,Oct 2024

JFK - ATL

Overall it was good on the flight. Before the flight with checking the bag at JFK was a nightmare. It took way too long and the Delta concierge was very rude to everyone. But other than that it was fine.
United Airlines
7.4
Good
9,177 reviews
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews

Overall

7.9

Food

7.2

Boarding

8.1

Comfort

7.9

Crew

8.5

Entertainment

7.8

Reviews

1 / 20
10.0
Excellent

Kymberlee,Oct 2024

JFK - ATL

Overall it was good on the flight. Before the flight with checking the bag at JFK was a nightmare. It took way too long and the Delta concierge was very rude to everyone. But other than that it was fine.
American Airlines
7.2
Good
11,160 reviews
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews

Overall

7.9

Food

7.2

Boarding

8.1

Comfort

7.9

Crew

8.5

Entertainment

7.8

Reviews

1 / 20
10.0
Excellent

Kymberlee,Oct 2024

JFK - ATL

Overall it was good on the flight. Before the flight with checking the bag at JFK was a nightmare. It took way too long and the Delta concierge was very rude to everyone. But other than that it was fine.
Spirit Airlines
6.3
Okay
8,348 reviews
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews

Overall

7.9

Food

7.2

Boarding

8.1

Comfort

7.9

Crew

8.5

Entertainment

7.8

Reviews

1 / 20
10.0
Excellent

Kymberlee,Oct 2024

JFK - ATL

Overall it was good on the flight. Before the flight with checking the bag at JFK was a nightmare. It took way too long and the Delta concierge was very rude to everyone. But other than that it was fine.
Frontier
5.7
Fair
3,058 reviews
Delta
7.9
Good
8,075 reviews

Overall

7.9

Food

7.2

Boarding

8.1

Comfort

7.9

Crew

8.5

Entertainment

7.8

Reviews

1 / 20
10.0
Excellent

Kymberlee,Oct 2024

JFK - ATL

Overall it was good on the flight. Before the flight with checking the bag at JFK was a nightmare. It took way too long and the Delta concierge was very rude to everyone. But other than that it was fine.

Related info for your journey

Find useful and relevant information for your journey from New York to Islamorada. Access travel guides, tips, and recommendations to enhance your travel experience. Get information about local attractions, weather, transportation options, and more.

  • How long is the flight from New York to Islamorada?

    Airlines like Spirit Airlines, United Airlines, and Delta fly from New York to Islamorada in about 3h 20m. The time it takes to get you to your destination is usually consistent. The distance between New York and Islamorada is about 1098 mi. Most flights are nonstop.

  • What are the cheapest airlines to fly from New York to Islamorada one-way?

    To fly one-way, consider booking your trip with Frontier, which is currently one of the cheapest options available, starting at $27. Spirit Airlines flights start at $33 while deals on JetBlue start at $63 one-way.

  • What are the most popular routes from New York to Islamorada?

    The most popular route from New York to Islamorada is New York John F Kennedy Intl - Miami. You may also consider Newark - Miami or New York LaGuardia - Miami.

  • What are the most reliable airlines from New York to Islamorada?

    Looking for the most reliable airlines to get you to your destination on time? Our data shows these are most likely to get you from New York to Islamorada on time: China Southern (88%), Malaysia Airlines (86%), American Airlines (85%).

  • What are the cheapest flights from New York to Islamorada?

    The cheapest flight price from New York to Islamorada is $45. On average you can expect to pay $533. The most popular route, (New York John F Kennedy Intl - Miami), can usually be booked for $56.

  • Can I find deals for flights from New York to Islamorada that include hotel bookings?

    Yes. In addition to deals on New York to Islamorada flights, Cheapflights offers vacation packages that include both flights and hotel.

  • How can I find direct flights from New York to Islamorada?

    After entering your origin and destination, apply the non-stop filter on the search result page to find direct flights from New York to Islamorada.

  • Can I find deals for business class flights from New York to Islamorada?

    Yes. Cheapflights offers flight deals from New York to Islamorada by cabin class. In addition to browsing deals, you can also filter by cabin class on the search results page after making a search.

  • What is the cheapest month to book a flight from New York to Islamorada?

    Currently, March is the cheapest month in which you can book a flight from New York to Islamorada (average of $36). Flying from New York to Islamorada in July is currently the most expensive (average of $85). There are several factors that can impact the price of a flight, so comparing airlines, departure airports and flight times can provide users with more options.

See more FAQs

Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip

Toggle through the tabs below to find thousands of options on Cheapflights for your next trip.

Alternative routes for New York to Islamorada

See prices for flight routes from nearby airports that may be better suited for you.
John F Kennedy Intl to Fort Lauderdale flights
Newark to Miami flights
Newark to Fort Lauderdale flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Miami flights
John F Kennedy Intl to West Palm Beach flights
LaGuardia to Fort Lauderdale flights
LaGuardia to Miami flights
Newark to West Palm Beach flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Orlando flights
Newark to Orlando flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Tampa flights
LaGuardia to Orlando flights
Newark to Tampa flights
LaGuardia to West Palm Beach flights
LaGuardia to Tampa flights
Newark to Fort Myers flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Fort Myers flights
White Plains to Orlando flights
LaGuardia to Fort Myers flights
Newark to Sarasota flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Sarasota flights
White Plains to Fort Lauderdale flights
Newark to Jacksonville flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Jacksonville flights
Buffalo to Orlando flights
Islip to Orlando flights
White Plains to Tampa flights
Syracuse to Orlando flights
White Plains to West Palm Beach flights
LaGuardia to Sarasota flights
White Plains to Miami flights
Newark to Key West flights
Islip to West Palm Beach flights
Stewart to Fort Lauderdale flights
White Plains to Fort Myers flights
Albany to Orlando flights
Stewart to Orlando flights
Rochester to Orlando flights
Islip to Fort Lauderdale flights
LaGuardia to Jacksonville flights
Buffalo to Fort Lauderdale flights
LaGuardia to Key West flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Key West flights
Buffalo to Tampa flights
John F Kennedy Intl to Daytona Beach flights
Islip to Tampa flights
Stewart to St Petersburg flights
Islip to Fort Myers flights
Newark to Daytona Beach flights
Albany to Fort Lauderdale flights

Top 9 airlines flying from New York to Islamorada

Discover the top 9 airlines that operate flights from New York to Islamorada. Compare their services, reliability, and customer satisfaction ratings to choose the airline that best suits your travel preferences and needs. Over the last 7 days, Cheapflights users made 2,558,603 searches. Data last updated January 19, 2026.
AirlineCheapestAverageFlexibilityOn-time
FrontierCheapest$26Average$164FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time62%
Allegiant AirCheapest$49Average$137FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time88%
Spirit AirlinesCheapest$59Average$194FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time65%
JetBlueCheapest$73Average$290FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time62%
DeltaCheapest$73Average$332FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-timeN/A
SouthwestCheapest$100Average$376FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time63%
United AirlinesCheapest$127Average$360FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time69%
American AirlinesCheapest$127Average$363FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time71%
Alaska AirlinesCheapest$128Average$156FlexibilityNo cancel feeOn-time75%

100% Free

Cheapflights is completely free to use, so you can start saving the moment you arrive.

Book with Flexibility

Our users can plan ahead with confidence and find flights with no change fees

Travel Smart

Millions of people come to us for their flight needs every year. We help make travel planning easy by providing useful insights and data-driven graphs that can inform your decisions.