Cheap Car Rentals in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York from $35
This price is the cheapest per day rate found by a Cheapflights user in the last 48 hours by searching for a car rental in Randalls and Wards Islands with a pick-up date of 10/14 and drop-off date of 10/25. Fares are subject to change and may not be available at all agencies or on all dates of rental.
Same drop-off
Noon
Noon
We work with more than 300 partners to bring you better travel deals
Randalls and Wards Islands, New York car rentals in 2026
Get helpful information to start your search for the perfect car rental in Randalls and Wards Islands. The average price data is based on the last 12 months and was last updated on September 16, 2026.
Most popular company | Budget |
|---|---|
Most common car type | Intermediate |
Average price per day | $88 |
Cheapest price per day | $35 |
Best Randalls and Wards Islands, New York car rental deals
Browse through the best deals we’ve found on Randalls and Wards Islands car rental deals at this time. Deals are sourced from providers and were last updated on September 16, 2026.
Toyota Prius$38/day
Subaru Outback$49/day
Tesla Model Y$38/day
Cheapflights insights for Randalls and Wards Islands car rentals
Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.
How far in advance should I rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands?
Book your rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands 7 days before your pickup date to maximize your savings Car rental prices are around $43/day on average when booked 7 days ahead, which saves you 32% off the usual average price.
What is the cheapest rental car company in Randalls and Wards Islands?
In Randalls and Wards Islands, the most affordable rental car company right now is Ace, offering prices from just $8.41/day over the past two weeks. Another budget-friendly choice is Sixt, with rates starting at $25.67/day.
What is the best car rental company in Randalls and Wards Islands?
Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest rated car rental company in Randalls and Wards Islands is Sixt (rated 6.6/10 with 39 reviews). Hertz (rated 6.2/10 with 43 reviews) is also highly rated by our users.
Sixt
6.6
Hertz
6.2
Budget
5.7
Ace
4.4
What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Randalls and Wards Islands?
Planning a car rental in Randalls and Wards Islands? January is the cheapest month, costing about $42 per day. In contrast, July is the most expensive, with an average daily rate of $95. Monthly average rental prices are listed below. Remember, prices can change based on when you book, the type of car, and availability.
January
$42
February
$46
March
$52
April
$58
May
$63
June
$85
July
$95
August
$84
September
$51
October
$58
November
$60
December
$60
Top rental agencies in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York
Explore the most popular car rental suppliers in Randalls and Wards Islands, including their locations and customer reviews, to make the best choice for your next trip.
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Sixt
39 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
7.1
Comfort
7.2
Overall
6.6
Pick-up/drop-off
6.5
Value
6.6
Recent reviews
10.0
|Feb 2025Everyone was genuinely warm friendly and helpful inn every way. And there was barely any waiting. They didn’t have the exact car I’d chosen so they gave me an upgrade and it was a great car. Thanks so much to you all.
2.0
|May 2022I was not able to pick up my car because they closed at 5pm at a major airport on a Friday, leaving me stranded
2.0
|May 2022I ordered a rental cause my car was in the shop. A day or two later I got a call my car was ready. I canceled my order but you have to pay a $100 cancellation fee regardless of how many days you are from reservation. If you create a rental and then an hour later you cancel? $100.
2.0
|Apr 2022Communication/messaging of store hours would be helpful. Would be great if I was able to input arrival and departure upon reservation or the ability to modifying. Would be great if you call center prompts had more options or a human being to speak with
8.0
|Apr 2022The pick up and drop off experience were great. The shuttles from the airport were nice and the drivers friendly. The only issue is that after we dropped off the car, and an employee looked at everything with us standing there, the next day they claimed there were scratches. It was impossible for us to have made them. We picked up the car, stopped at a convenience store (only one person went in) stopped to fill up before dropping it off (again, only 1 person left the car) and we dropped it off. We told them this, and they didn't contact us again, so it ended up ok. But, would've been even better without that potential incident.
2.0
|Apr 2022Customer service was the worst I've ever experienced. Communication was terrible. I will never use Sixt again.
1 out of 13
View Sixt Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Hertz
43 reviews•2 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
7.0
Comfort
7.0
Overall
6.2
Pick-up/drop-off
6.2
Value
6.1
Recent reviews
2.0
|Jul 2023Hertz charged me a completely different rate than what I booked through Kayak. I ended up paying more with Kayak than if I had just booked it myself.
2.0
|Jul 2023Waited. Nearly an hour to be served at the counter. Then waited another hour for a car to be available. Shouldn’t have to wait two hours for a car when one is on time for the reservation.
1 out of 15
View Hertz Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Budget
99 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
6.7
Comfort
6.7
Overall
5.7
Pick-up/drop-off
5.7
Value
6.0
Recent reviews
2.0
|Nov 2023t
2.0
|Jul 2023Ok, so it was the Friday afternoon before the Fourth of July but it took 45 minutes on line waiting to get assigned a car. What a nightmare. Once you got your little piece of paper then you had to wait outside for some poor guy who is running around trying to help everyone to actually assign you a car. Completely disorganized and inefficient I won’t book with budget again.
2.0
|Jun 2023There was a 2 hour line to pick up my vehicle
10.0
|Mar 2023Budget at LaGuardia Airport was fast, easy, and the staff friendly for both rental and return. Easy to find offsite location. Shuttle was fast with helpful and friendly drivers.
1 out of 33
View Budget Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Ace
75 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
5.5
Comfort
5.3
Overall
4.4
Pick-up/drop-off
4.7
Value
4.6
Recent reviews
2.0
|May 2025I did not receive the car yet the insurance refuse to refund me.
10.0
|Jan 2025Get a cheaper rate and also allow to use two credit cards
2.0
|Nov 2024The company was not up front with their pricing for unlimited miles. I used the car to travel to Massachusetts and Rhode Island but also needed to go to New Hampshire. This company charges additional money to take the car to New Hampshire. Had I known this prior to booking I would not have booked with this company. Unfortunately, I only found out when I arrived at the booking site in person and it was already too late.
2.0
|Aug 2024Returned the car on time an hour early and still got charged a late fee
2.0
|Mar 2023These people are total crooks and were extremely rude to me for absolutely no reason.
2.0
|Jan 2023This company doesn’t honor the insurance that is pre paid in your website. People behind de counter are very arrogant and condescending towards customers.
1 out of 25
View Ace Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Locations
Advantage
1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
10.0
Comfort
10.0
Overall
10.0
Pick-up/drop-off
10.0
Value
10.0
View Advantage Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Locations
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
8.3
Comfort
8.2
Overall
8.2
Pick-up/drop-off
8.3
Value
7.8
View Enterprise Rent-A-Car Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Payless
15 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
7.5
Comfort
7.4
Overall
7.3
Pick-up/drop-off
7.2
Value
7.3
Recent reviews
2.0
|Aug 2024They didn’t have cars available for me and the 13 people in front of me. No communication while we wait for hours
1 out of 5
View Payless Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Overview
Locations
Dollar
22 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
6.2
Comfort
6.1
Overall
5.1
Pick-up/drop-off
5.1
Value
5.1
View Dollar Locations in Randalls and Wards Islands
Randalls and Wards Islands Car rental FAQs
Find answers to frequently asked questions about car rentals in Randalls and Wards Islands, including policies, requirements, and more. FAQs were last updated on September 16, 2026.
Can I rent a car for a month at Randalls and Wards Islands?
Yes, renting a vehicle at Randalls and Wards Islands for a month is certainly possible.
What is the cheapest rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York?
A Hyundai Accent, for $34 per day on average, is the cheapest rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York. This price is 21% cheaper than other rental cars in Randalls and Wards Islands.
How much is a rental car in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York?
Rental car prices in Randalls and Wards Islands, New York will vary depending on when you book, but at the moment you can expect a rental to cost $34 per day on average and as low as $35 per day.
Car rentals by fuel type in Randalls and Wards Islands
Browse car rentals by fuel type in Randalls and Wards Islands. Currently, Hybrid cars are the cheapest to rent in Randalls and Wards Islands. Deals were last updated on September 16, 2026.
Browse through car rental deals by fuel type in Randalls and Wards Islands. There are currently 3 fuel types to choose from with Hybrid being the cheapest ($37+).
Electric
$37+
Gas/Diesel
$49+
Hybrid
$37+
Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip
Toggle through the tabs below to find thousands of options on Cheapflights for your next trip.
Rental Cars at Airports
Rental Cars in Other Neighborhoods
Rental Cars Worldwide
Rentals in Other New York State Cities
Car Rentals in Cities
Complete your trip
New York State Vacation Packages