Cheap Car Rentals in Little Italy, New York from $5
This price is the cheapest per day rate found by a Cheapflights user in the last 48 hours by searching for a car rental in Little Italy with a pick-up date of 11/6 and drop-off date of 11/29. Fares are subject to change and may not be available at all agencies or on all dates of rental.
Same drop-off
Noon
Noon
We work with more than 300 partners to bring you better travel deals
Best Little Italy, New York car rental deals
Browse through the best deals we’ve found on Little Italy car rental deals at this time. Deals are sourced from providers and were last updated on October 25, 2026.
Ford Fiesta$5/day
Nissan Rogue$5/day
Mercedes-Benz GLC$5/day
Cheapflights insights for Little Italy car rentals
Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in Little Italy, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.
What is the best car rental company in Little Italy?
Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest rated car rental company in Little Italy is Alamo (rated 8.3/10 with 10 reviews). Enterprise Rent-A-Car (rated 8.2/10 with 2 reviews) is also highly rated by our users.
Alamo
8.3
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
8.2
Routes Car & Truck Rentals
8.0
National
7.6
Top rental agencies in Little Italy, New York
Explore the most popular car rental suppliers in Little Italy, including their locations and customer reviews, to make the best choice for your next trip.
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Alamo
10 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
8.5
Comfort
8.6
Overall
8.3
Pick-up/drop-off
8.4
Value
8.3
Recent reviews
10.0
|Apr 2023Maybe just a sign pointing that the rental office is down the ramp, but that's it.
2.0
|Mar 2023Drop-off location was not running the advertised scheduled shuttle, still have not received final receipt.
1 out of 4
View Alamo Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Locations
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
2 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
8.3
Comfort
8.2
Overall
8.2
Pick-up/drop-off
8.3
Value
7.8
View Enterprise Rent-A-Car Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Locations
Routes Car & Truck Rentals
1 location
View Routes Car & Truck Rentals Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Locations
National
1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
8.0
Comfort
7.6
Overall
7.6
Pick-up/drop-off
7.6
Value
7.2
View National Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Hertz
10 reviews•2 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
7.0
Comfort
7.0
Overall
6.2
Pick-up/drop-off
6.1
Value
6.1
Recent reviews
2.0
|Apr 2023They did not honor my reservation. When I arrived, I was told I had the option of cancelling my reservation or going on a waiting list. They were expecting at most two cars to return, and I was sixth on the waiting list.
1 out of 4
View Hertz Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Locations
VIPCars Recommendation
1 location
View VIPCars Recommendation Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Locations
Drive Tri-State
1 location
View Drive Tri-State Locations in Little Italy
Overview
Locations
Apollo Car Rentals
1 location
View Apollo Car Rentals Locations in Little Italy
Little Italy Car rental FAQs
Find answers to frequently asked questions about car rentals in Little Italy, including policies, requirements, and more. FAQs were last updated on October 25, 2026.
Can I rent a car for a month at Little Italy?
The length of time you can book a rental for is subject to the inventory of the supplier. When renting a vehicle from Little Italy it should be possible to rent a car for a whole month if needed.
Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip
Toggle through the tabs below to find thousands of options on Cheapflights for your next trip.
Rental Cars at Airports
Rental Cars in Other Neighborhoods
Rental Cars Worldwide
Rentals in Other New York State Cities
Car Rentals in Cities
Complete your trip
New York State Vacation Packages