Cheap Car Rentals in Elmira, NY from $35
This price is the cheapest per day rate found by a Cheapflights user in the last 48 hours by searching for a car rental in Elmira with a pick-up date of 5/21 and drop-off date of 5/28. Fares are subject to change and may not be available at all agencies or on all dates of rental.
Elmira, NY car rentals in 2026
Get helpful information to start your search for the perfect car rental in Elmira, NY. The average price data is based on the last 12 months and was last updated on February 17, 2026.
Most popular company | DOLLAR |
|---|---|
Price of gas per gallon | $3.26 |
Average price per day | $48 |
Cheapest price per day | $35 |
Compare car rental deals in Elmira, NY by type
Here are the best Elmira small car rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:
Here are the best Elmira medium car rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:
Here are the best Elmira large car rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:
Here are the best Elmira SUV rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:
Here are the best Elmira van rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:
Here are the best Elmira luxury car rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:
Best car rental deals found in Elmira
Browse through a selection of recently found affordable car rental deals in Elmira, NY. Plan your trip with ease and find the perfect rental option for your needs. There are currently 8 rental car agencies in Elmira, NY with an average daily rate of $51. Data was last updated on February 17, 2026.
Cheapflights insights for Elmira car rentals
Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in Elmira, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.
How far in advance should I rent a car in Elmira?
Book your rental car in Elmira 76 days before your pickup date to maximize your savings Car rental prices are around $49/day on average when booked 76 days ahead, which saves you 31% off the usual average price.
What is the best car rental company in Elmira?
Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest rated car rental company in Elmira is National (rated 8.5/10). Hertz (rated 6.8/10 with 4 reviews) is also highly rated by our users.
What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Elmira?
Planning a car rental in Elmira? January is the cheapest month, costing about $57 per day. In contrast, August is the most expensive, with an average daily rate of $96. Monthly average rental prices are listed below. Remember, prices can change based on when you book, the type of car, and availability.
January
$57
February
$58
March
$62
April
$70
May
$69
June
$79
July
$88
August
$96
September
$58
October
$73
November
$74
December
$67
What car do most people rent in Elmira?
SUV rentals (Chevrolet Suburban, for example) are the most popular in Elmira. Intermediate (Toyota Camry) and Full-size (Class Commercial Truck) rentals are also often chosen by our users when visiting Elmira.
Which car rental company has the most locations in Elmira?
Enterprise Rent-A-Car has 2 locations throughout the area, more than any other company. AutoEurope has the second highest number of locations in Elmira at 1.
Top rental agencies in Elmira, NY
Explore the leading car rental agencies in Elmira, NY known for their outstanding service and extensive range of vehicles to choose from. There are currently 8 car rental companies in Elmira, NY. Reviews were last updated on February 17, 2026.
National
View National Locations in Elmira
Hertz
Overview
Cleanliness
Comfort
Overall
Pick-up/drop-off
Value
View Hertz Locations in Elmira
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
Recent reviews
View Enterprise Rent-A-Car Locations in Elmira
AutoEurope
View AutoEurope Locations in Elmira
Avis
View Avis Locations in Elmira
Budget
View Budget Locations in Elmira
Easirent
View Easirent Locations in Elmira
Dollar
View Dollar Locations in Elmira
Car rental FAQs
Find answers to frequently asked questions about car rentals in Elmira, NY, including policies, requirements, and more. FAQs were last updated on February 17, 2026.
What is the cheapest rental car found in Elmira?
In the past two weeks, Cheapflights users have found many deals under $48/day when booking a rental car in Elmira. The best deal a user found was for $31/day from Dollar, booked on Feb. 7.
How much does it cost to rent a car in Elmira for a week from Dollar?
Dollar is a popular option for travelers looking for car rental in Elmira. You can expect the average cost of rental car to be about $361 per week.
Can I rent a car for a month in Elmira?
The length of time you can book a rental for is subject to the inventory of the supplier. When renting a vehicle from Elmira it should be possible to rent a car for a whole month if needed.
How much does it cost to rent a car in Elmira for a month?
Our recent data shows that Dollar can potentially be 47% below the average car rental price in Elmira. Check prices and availability for Dollar and save on this extended rental. The cost of renting a vehicle in Elmira is on average $1,549 a month or $52 a day. Search on Cheapflights for the most updated pricing and availability for your Elmira car rental.
How much is a car rental in Elmira for a weekend?
$52 is, on average, how much a car rental costs for the weekend in Elmira. To save money, consider booking a Economy car rental, which is the cheapest car during the weekend. If you are looking for a car rental in March, we’ve seen prices on Cheapflights for as low as $50 per day.