Regardless of the time of day you decide to fly, the ticket price will remain around the same. Book flights from New York to Moloka'i as you normally would.
Hawaiian Airlines is one of the carriers that may have flexible change policies. You can use our site to filter for other airlines that may also have this kind of flexibility.
Yes, there are multiple flights from New York to Moloka'i for under $1,400. The cheapest flight booked recently is on Multiple Airlines for just $1,303, but on average you can expect to pay $1,303.
The most popular route from New York to Moloka'i is Newark - Hoolehua Molokai. You may also consider New York John F Kennedy Intl - Hoolehua Molokai or New York LaGuardia - Hoolehua Molokai.