Key West

Cheap Car Rentals in Key West

Same drop-off
Key West, FL
Mon 10/3
Noon
Mon 10/10
Noon
We work with more than 300 partners to bring you better travel deals

Key West Car Rentals in 2022

Most popular companyTHRIFTY
Price of gas per gallon$3.97
Average price per day$64
Cheapest price per day$29

What is the cheapest time to rent a car in Key West?

January

$77

February

$83

March

$89

April

$88

May

$77

June

$78

July

$81

August

$78

September

$70

October

$79

November

$88

December

$85

Currently, the cheapest month to rent a car in Key West is September. The most expensive time to rent a car is March. The cheapest prices for each month are shown above, but prices will vary based on availability, how far out you book your rental car, and of course, car type.

Compare available car types for rental in Key West

Small Cars

$49 - $84

All Car Types

$75 - $115

To rent a Small car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $67/day. September is the cheapest month to rent a Small car in Key West, the United States (~$49/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is March (~$84/day). In fact, September is about 27% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a Small rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a Small car saves you 30% in costs. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity. Here are the best Key West Small rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:

To rent a Medium car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $82/day. September is the cheapest month to rent a Medium car in Key West, the United States (~$66/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is April (~$106/day). In fact, September is about 21% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a Medium rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a Medium car saves you 13% in costs. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity. Here are the best Key West Medium rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:

To rent a Large car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $89/day. September is the cheapest month to rent a Large car in Key West, the United States (~$65/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is February (~$138/day). In fact, September is about 28% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a Large rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a Large car saves you 6% in costs. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity. Here are the best Key West Large rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:

To rent a SUV car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $91/day. September is the cheapest month to rent a SUV car in Key West, the United States (~$67/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is March (~$117/day). In fact, September is about 27% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a SUV rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a SUV car saves you 5% in costs. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity. Here are the best Key West SUV rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:

To rent a Van car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $124/day. September is the cheapest month to rent a Van car in Key West, the United States (~$108/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is April (~$157/day). In fact, September is about 13% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a Van rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a Van car is 24% more expensive. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity.

To rent a Luxury car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $100/day. September is the cheapest month to rent a Luxury car in Key West, the United States (~$77/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is December (~$116/day). In fact, September is about 24% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a Luxury rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a Luxury car is 6% more expensive. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity. Here are the best Key West Luxury rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:

To rent a Convertible car in Key West, the United States, you would pay an average price of $109/day. January is the cheapest month to rent a Convertible car in Key West, the United States (~$87/day), while the most expensive month to rent that same car type is April (~$147/day). In fact, January is about 21% cheaper than prices during the rest of the year to book a Convertible rental for Key West. When comparing with other car types available for rental in Key West, renting a Convertible car is 14% more expensive. Please note that average prices are based on historical data and can vary depending on how early you book, availability for your travel dates, and vehicle popularity. Here are the best Key West Convertible rental prices found by Cheapflights users in the past 7 days:

Kia Soul$34/day
4
M
A/C
Kia Soul
Kia Rio$32/day
2
4
M
A/C
Kia Rio

Top rental agencies in Key West

All major car rental suppliers in Key West
6.1
Good
37 reviews1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

7.6

Comfort

7.2

Overall

6.1

Pick-up/drop-off

5.2

Value

6.7
5.6
Okay
55 reviews1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

5.9

Comfort

6.1

Overall

5.6

Pick-up/drop-off

5.5

Value

5.3
4.5
Okay
37 reviews1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

5.1

Comfort

5.0

Overall

4.4

Pick-up/drop-off

4.4

Value

4.2
9.4
Excellent
21 reviews1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

10.0

Comfort

10.0

Overall

9.0

Pick-up/drop-off

9.0

Value

9.0
6.1
Good
20 reviews1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

7.2

Comfort

6.9

Overall

6.1

Pick-up/drop-off

5.5

Value

6.6
5.0
Okay
14 reviews1 location
Overview

Cleanliness

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Overall

5.0

Pick-up/drop-off

4.5

Value

5.0
4.8
Okay
15 reviews2 locations
Overview

Cleanliness

5.6

Comfort

6.3

Overall

4.8

Pick-up/drop-off

4.4

Value

4.8
2.0
Mediocre
1 review2 locations
Overview

Cleanliness

2.0

Comfort

6.0

Overall

2.0

Pick-up/drop-off

2.0

Value

2.0

Best Key West Car Rental Deals Found

Check out some of the best deals for car rentals in Key West recently found.

Car Rental FAQs

What is the cheapest rental car found in Key West?

In the past two weeks, Cheapflights users have found many deals under $64/day when booking a rental car in Key West. The best deal a user found was for $29/day from Thrifty, booked on Jul. 28.

What car rental company is typically the cheapest in Key West?

According to our data, users have found the cheapest deals when booking a rental car in Key West from the following companies over the past two weeks: Alamo ($34/day), Dollar ($40/day), and Budget ($48/day).

Which car rental company is considered to be the best in Key West?

Taking our users’ ratings and reviews into consideration, Thrifty (9.4 rating), Avis (6.8 rating) and Dollar (6.3 rating) seem to be the best rental car companies in Key West.

What are gas prices like in Key West?

The average gas price in Key West is $3.97/gallon over the past month, costing you anywhere between $47 and $68 to fill up a car’s gas tank.

How much does it cost to rent a car in Key West for a week from Thrifty?

Thrifty is one of the top picks in Key West. They can have you in a rental car for about $351 per week on average.

Can I rent a car for a month in Key West?

Typically how long you can rent a car for depends on the inventory of the supplier. For Key West however, it is certainly possible to rent a car for an entire month.

How much does it cost to rent a car in Key West for a month?

Thrifty currently has the lowest price available for a month-long booking. Users have saved up to 56% compared to the average price of a 30-day rental in Key West. Typically, a monthly car rental in Key West can be found for $1,506. You can find car rental deals to be on average $50 a day.

How much is a car rental in Key West for a weekend?

The average price for a weekend car rental in Key West is $85. Renting a Economy is your cheapest option if you’ve looking to save money on your weekend car rental in Key West. For the month of October, Cheapflights users have found rental cars in Key West for as low as $81/day.