Cheap Car Rentals in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island from $17
This price is the cheapest per day rate found by a Cheapflights user in the last 48 hours by searching for a car rental in Water Island with a pick-up date of 9/17 and drop-off date of 9/24. Fares are subject to change and may not be available at all agencies or on all dates of rental.
Same drop-off
Noon
Noon
We work with more than 300 partners to bring you better travel deals
Water Island, Saint Thomas Island car rentals in 2026
Get helpful information to start your search for the perfect car rental in Water Island. The average price data is based on the last 12 months and was last updated on September 8, 2026.
Most popular company | Budget |
|---|---|
Most common car type | SUV |
Average price per day | $62 |
Cheapest price per day | $17 |
Best Water Island, Saint Thomas Island car rental deals
Browse through the best deals we’ve found on Water Island car rental deals at this time. Deals are sourced from providers and were last updated on September 8, 2026.
Nissan Versa$20/day
Dodge Journey$54/day
Ford Edge$61/day
Cheapflights insights for Water Island car rentals
Get relevant, data-driven information to help you rent a car in Water Island, including pricing trends, ideal booking times, and more.
How far in advance should I rent a car in Water Island?
To get the best deal on a rental car in Water Island, book about 8 days before your trip. At that point, average daily prices are around $50, which is about 15% cheaper than the typical rate.
What is the cheapest rental car company in Water Island?
Budget is currently the cheapest rental car company in Water Island with deals as low as $15.79/day found in the past two weeks. Enterprise Rent-A-Car is another inexpensive option with rates as low as $20.73/day.
What is the best car rental company in Water Island?
Based on Cheapflights user feedback, the highest rated car rental company in Water Island is Budget (rated 6.1/10 with 42 reviews). National (rated 10.0/10 with 1 review) is also highly rated by our users.
Budget
6.1
National
10.0
Alamo
9.0
Ace
7.5
What is the cheapest month to rent a car in Water Island?
The cheapest month to rent a car in Water Island is September where you can expect to pay $43/day on average. The most expensive month to rent a car in Water Island is February ($71/day on average). The average daily rental price for each month is shown below. Keep in mind that prices will vary based on availability, when you book, and the type of car you rent.
January
$65
February
$71
March
$64
April
$64
May
$61
June
$61
July
$63
August
$53
September
$43
October
$46
November
$46
December
$67
Top rental agencies in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island
Explore the most popular car rental suppliers in Water Island, including their locations and customer reviews, to make the best choice for your next trip.
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Budget
42 reviews•2 locations
Overview
Cleanliness
6.8
Comfort
7.1
Overall
6.1
Pick-up/drop-off
6.1
Value
5.9
Recent reviews
2.0
|Jan 2026Terrible extra charges that were not agreed to. Lied and told the law required extra coverage. Charged for fuel when I filled up across the street to be told I’d have to take that up with inside counter. Scammers everywhere.
1 out of 14
View Budget Locations in Water Island
Overview
Locations
National
1 review•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
10.0
Comfort
10.0
Overall
10.0
Pick-up/drop-off
10.0
Value
10.0
View National Locations in Water Island
Overview
Locations
Alamo
1 review•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
10.0
Comfort
9.0
Overall
9.0
Pick-up/drop-off
10.0
Value
9.0
View Alamo Locations in Water Island
Overview
Locations
Ace
1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
7.2
Comfort
7.8
Overall
7.5
Pick-up/drop-off
7.0
Value
7.2
View Ace Locations in Water Island
Overview
Locations
Dollar
3 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
6.8
Comfort
6.8
Overall
6.3
Pick-up/drop-off
6.8
Value
6.2
View Dollar Locations in Water Island
Overview
Reviews
Locations
Hertz
11 reviews•1 location
Overview
Cleanliness
6.5
Comfort
6.1
Overall
4.3
Pick-up/drop-off
4.8
Value
3.8
Recent reviews
4.0
|Jul 2023They didn’t have the size car I ordered and was charged to “upgrade” to a car that I essentially ordered. Website needs to be more transparent on what is being ordered.
2.0
|Jul 2023I booked and paid for a luxury SUV, and was booked a small SUV upon receipt. No way of contacting Kayak rental service to report at time of rental. Once arrived at air port, I had to pay an extra +$250.00 for a Mid-size SUV. We had a party of 6 people. During entire trip we had someone sitting on one’s lap or I the very back of suv, rear access. Whole trip I was concerned that we had one person that was not secured via seat belt. Not sure if this will help matters or any action will be taken by Kayak, but I did feel to express my concerns.
10.0
|Jul 2023Awesome experience. Super quick check in and check out. Great car. Friendly service.
1 out of 4
View Hertz Locations in Water Island
Overview
Locations
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
1 location
View Enterprise Rent-A-Car Locations in Water Island
Overview
Locations
Apex
1 location
View Apex Locations in Water Island
Water Island Car rental FAQs
Find answers to frequently asked questions about car rentals in Water Island, including policies, requirements, and more. FAQs were last updated on September 8, 2026.
Can I rent a car for a month at Water Island?
Yes, renting a vehicle at Water Island for a month is certainly possible.
What is the cheapest rental car in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island?
At an average cost of $17/day, the cheapest rental car in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island is the Toyota Yaris. Based on our data, it’s 58% cheaper to rent a Toyota Yaris compared to other types of rental cars in the neighborhood.
How much is a rental car in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island?
A rental car in Water Island, Saint Thomas Island costs $17/day on average, though we’ve seen prices as low as $17/day recently.
Browse thousands of different options on Cheapflights for your next trip
Toggle through the tabs below to find thousands of options on Cheapflights for your next trip.
Rental Cars at Airports
Rental Cars in Other Neighborhoods
Rental Cars Worldwide
Rentals in Other Saint Thomas Cities
Car Rentals in Cities
Complete your trip
the U.S. Virgin Islands Vacation Packages