When searching for a good deal, it’s best to be prepared for potential fluctuations in price. We recommend booking at least 37 days in advance, which can save you up to 3% on flights from New York to Iceland compared to booking the week you need them. Waiting 37 days out may not be for everyone, so we have options available for flights within the next two weeks, with the lowest price starting at $784. For sooner than that we have options available in the next 3 days from $787.
Our data shows that July tends to be the cheapest month to fly to Iceland from New York. Users have commonly found prices around $753 for the month, but tickets can be as low as $591. Due to multiple factors, prepare for potentially higher prices in December.